Wishlistr AlternativeYour wants, or your people?
Wishlistr is a simple universal wishlist you can fill from any store. Thoughtful is about the people you give to: their dates, their history with you, and the card you are about to write.
Competitor features and prices checked November 2026 from their own sites and App Store listings. They change, so check before you buy.
How they're different
Wishlistr keeps a list of what you want, shareable with anyone. Thoughtful keeps a record of the people you give to and nudges you before the moments that matter. One faces inward, at your wants; the other faces outward, at the people you care about.
Thoughtful is for you if…
You want to remember occasions, write the card, and keep a memory of every gift you give so you never double up.
Wishlistr is for you if…
You want a free, simple, store-agnostic wishlist to share when people ask what you want.
Feature-by-feature
| Feature | Thoughtful | Wishlistr |
|---|---|---|
| People + occasions + reminders | Yes | No |
| Universal shareable wishlist | Wishlist sharing | Yes |
| AI card drafting in your voice | Yes | No |
| Gift-given memory (repeat warnings) | Yes | No |
| Print-and-mail card flow | No | No |
| Free tier | 7-day free trial on annual Pro | Yes |
| Pricing | Pro subscription (weekly or annual) | Free |
Where Thoughtful is better
- • Best for remembering the people and the dates.
- • Best for writing the card that comes with the gift.
- • Best for tracking what you have given over the years.
Where Wishlistr is better
- • Best for a simple, free wishlist of your own.
- • Best for sharing a list when people ask what you want.
- • Best if a single list is all you need.
The bottom line
Wishlistr is a perfectly good place to keep your own wants. Thoughtful answers a different question: how to be the person who remembers, writes, and shows up for others. If that is the part you find hard, that is the part Thoughtful was built for.